So before I review each album, I’m going to try to say something about each artist that makes them.
This is because I don’t want to keep repeating myself again in order to establish why a particular album matters when they’re from the same artist.
But also …And You Will Know Us By the Trail of Dead (a.k.a., TOD) presents a bit of a problem.
They have 11 albums in their discography. Every single one of them is good. So I’m going to review all of them. I’m not going to do this with every artist—because I just want to focus on the good stuff. But for TOD? Absolutely.
Discovering the future of rock n’ roll
The first time I heard this band, I was 17-years-old. I remember a zine mentioned their album Madonna—I forget which one. It got me curious enough to take the bus down to A&B Sound to give them a listen.
And I was absolutely blown away. That album sounded like the future of rock n’ roll. However, there was one problem: my parents were religious, and the cover art featured the Hindu goddess Kali. Buying the album was therefore out of the question.
So I looked at their debut album. It was selling for $10, had this amazing artwork of a battlefield with an elephant. And without even hearing it, I brought it home.
When no one was home, I put on the disc in the living room—and wow! What an opener! Still has to be one of the best openers on any album!
At this point I was thoroughly on the TOD train. I knew they were going to be a historic band.
Making history with Source Tags & Codes
And they proved me right with Source Tags & Codes. Damn, what a statement. Critics all agreed this was a monumental album. Pitchfork even gave them a 10/10—one of only 11 albums to accomplish this feat.
I was feeling triumphant. Clearly, TOD made an album on the same level as Pet Sounds and London Calling. They made history.
But sadly, TOD fell out of the zeitgeist.
The delivered World Apart. Everyone liked it. Stellar album. But it didn’t carry them into the mainstream, or even get adopted by indie subculture. TOD was not at as beloved as The Strokes or Arcade Fire. I’m not going to speculate why.
But even I noped out when they released So Divided.
Nevertheless, back in 2014, I made it a point to buy their self-titled debut album as well as Source Tags & Codes on vinyl. This was to be part of the greatest albums of all time book that I planned on writing—since abandoned, but maybe I will get to it eventually.
12 years later, I’m finally restarting my attempt.
And when I looked over their discography, I remembered something. You know, I’ve never heard anything after So Divided.
Therefore, this weekend, I made a specific decision to hear everything afterwards. That is, the albums released between 2009-22.
Surprisingly, TOD actually improved after So Divided. It is actually impressive. Not a single dud in their catalog.
It all culminates in XI: Bleed Here Now. If this is their final album, what a way to go. I don’t think they need to make anything else because what they’ve made is such a punctuation mark on their entire discography, where do you even go from here?
Giving Trail of Dead their just due
I am indeed going to try to review everything. This won’t be entirely hard because I’ve already reviewed two of their album elsewhere.
The hard part will be get each physical media of each album because I haven’t yet done that aspect of the work.
Nevertheless, I’m looking forward to talking about this band.
Because what I’ve realized is that TOD have not been given their just due. They were incredibly acclaimed during the early 2000s. In fact, on the vanguard of rock music. But over time, people have just forgotten about them—not because they aren’t good but for several other reasons I’ll discuss later.